Skip to content

Volatility as an Asset Class: Holding VIX in a Portfolio: summary and key takeaways

The paper asks whether VIX could work as a portfolio hedge for the S&P 500. A hypothetical cash VIX position adds alpha, but traded VIX products do not deliver it. A monthly SPX option spread, switched off when VIX is high, captures part of the benefit.

Doran, J.S. · 2020 · Journal of Futures MarketsSummary updated 20 November 2026
Published2020Journal article
Asset focusVolatility/VIXVIX hedging
TypePortfolio MgmtVolatility & VIX
Reading time5 minthis summary

Volatility as an Asset Class: Holding VIX in a Portfolio at a glance

The question
Can volatility be held as an asset alongside the S&P 500 to hedge downturns, and if VIX is not investable, can SPX options replicate it?
Dataset & period
Daily VIX levels from the CBOE; SPX option data from OptionMetrics, 1996 to 2017; S&P 500 returns from CRSP; Fama-French and momentum factors. Portfolios are formed and tested monthly.
Method
Monthly VIX returns are regressed on S&P 500 returns, squared returns and the prior VIX level, with up and down markets treated separately. The fitted relationship sets the VIX weight each month from earlier data only. Threshold rules drop the hedge when VIX rises above a set level. A regression of daily VIX changes on option price and moneyness changes then identifies which SPX options drive VIX, and an option spread portfolio is built from the answer.

Key findings of Volatility as an Asset Class: Holding VIX in a Portfolio

  • VIX and the S&P 500 are strongly negatively correlated, and the link is asymmetric: VIX rises much more in down months than it falls in up months.
  • In the full-sample regression, a 1% move in the S&P 500 goes with a 2.98% move in VIX.
  • A hypothetical hedge that sizes the VIX position by the fitted relationship averages a 5.05% allocation, and shows significant alpha after CAPM, Fama-French and option-factor controls.
  • Threshold level matters. Removing the VIX hedge when VIX exceeds its mean plus one standard deviation worked best; no threshold and too low a threshold both weakened results.
  • Portfolios hedged with VIX futures trail the cash VIX version by 44 basis point per month on the four-factor model and also trail the S&P 500 itself. Puts, VIX calls and VXX give similar results.
  • In-the-money puts have the strongest link to VIX changes, even though they are not used in the VIX formula. Buying an ITM-OTM put spread and selling an ATM-OTM call spread (VIXo+) keeps a high correlation to VIX at lower cost.
  • The VIXo+ portfolio with the mean-plus-one-standard-deviation switch returned 10.1% annualized, 1.8% above buy-and-hold, with lower volatility, after bid-ask spreads and transaction costs.

Robustness, as reported in the paper

  • Two sub-periods, 2007-2011 and 2013-2017, both show significant alphas for the cash VIX portfolio with the switch, including the low-volatility period.
  • The paper reports the VIX threshold result holds across different VIX allocations, but the supporting results are only available on request.
  • For the option replication, thresholds between the mean VIX level and mean plus two standard deviations changed returns little.
  • VIXo+ results include bid-ask spreads and transaction costs.

Caveats and limits

  • The cash VIX results are hypothetical because the VIX index cannot be bought directly; the paper says traded VIX products do not reproduce them.
  • Removing the hedge when VIX is high means the strategy misses extreme events. In 28 months with large S&P 500 losses, the average loss was -7.82% for the index, -3.73% for VIXo+ and -5.97% for the switched version.
  • Since 2011 the switched option portfolio has trailed the S&P 500 on raw return, because the covered-call leg did poorly; the paper says risk-adjusted results held up.
  • The threshold rule is chosen using the same sample it is tested on, so some look-back fit is possible (inferred).

Items marked (inferred) are our reading of the design, not statements by the authors.

Why it matters

The paper separates the volatility signal from the instruments used to trade it, and shows the instrument choice drives results. For practitioners, it shows why VIX futures and ETNs can fail as hedges while an option-based replica with a high-volatility off switch behaved differently in this sample. It also states plainly that tail events remain costly to hedge.

Questions about this paper

Does adding VIX futures or ETNs to an equity portfolio work as a hedge?

Not in this paper. Portfolios hedged with VIX futures trailed the cash VIX version by 44 basis point per month and also trailed the S&P 500.

Which options drive VIX changes?

In-the-money puts show the strongest relationship to VIX changes, although they are not part of the VIX calculation.

How did the option replica of VIX perform?

The VIXo+ portfolio with the high-VIX off switch returned 10.1% annualized, 1.8% above buy-and-hold, with lower volatility, after costs.

Where can I read the original paper?

The original is at its publisher: https://doi.org/10.1002/fut.22094. We link to the paper and do not host the PDF.

Follow new quant research

Download MacroFinance market data as CSV or Excel, or pull it by API, and test the ideas in these papers yourself. New summaries are added as we review them.

Create a free account
Summaries are written by MacroFinance from the published papers, in our own words, for information only. They are not investment advice and may omit detail. Papers are not hosted here: each page links to the original at its publisher.