Skip to content

Rebalance Timing Luck: The (Dumb) Luck of Smart Beta: summary and key takeaways

The paper builds long-only U.S. equity factor portfolios and varies only the rebalance dates. Identical strategies end up with large return gaps, driven by turnover, concentration and rebalance frequency. Replications of S&P 500 style indices show the same effect.

Hoffstein, C.; Faber, N.; Braun, S. · 2020 · SSRNSummary updated 20 November 2026
Published2020Working paper
Asset focusEquitiesRebalancing
TypePortfolio MgmtPortfolio Construction & Risk
Reading time4 minthis summary

Rebalance Timing Luck: The (Dumb) Luck of Smart Beta at a glance

The question
How much do returns of the same factor strategy differ purely because of when it rebalances?
Dataset & period
U.S. large-cap equities, S&P 500 as the parent universe, data from Sharadar, price history 2001 to 2019. Portfolios of 50 to 400 stocks in steps of 50, rebalanced annually, semi-annually or quarterly. Results are gross of fees.
Method
For each factor (value, quality, momentum, low volatility), the authors rank stocks and hold the top names equal weighted. They build one sub-index per possible rebalance schedule. They also build an RTL-neutral benchmark that holds all sub-indices in equal weight. Timing luck is measured as the annualized volatility of monthly return differences between each sub-index and that benchmark, and compared with a closed-form estimate from earlier work.

Key findings of Rebalance Timing Luck: The (Dumb) Luck of Smart Beta

  • Higher turnover and more concentrated portfolios show more timing luck. More frequent rebalancing and more holdings reduce it.
  • For semi-annual rebalancing of 100-stock portfolios, annualized timing luck reaches 2.5% for value, 4.4% for momentum, 1.1% for low volatility and 2.0% for quality.
  • That implies return dispersion of +/- 7.1, 12.5, 3.1 and 5.7 annual percentage points for the same four styles, from timing luck alone.
  • In replications of S&P 500 style indices, the annualized gap between best and worst rebalance schedule is 100, 192, 25 and 106 basis points for value, momentum, low volatility and quality.
  • In 2009, the JAN-JUL and JUN-DEC schedules of the value replication differed by 41.7 percentage points. Calendar-year gaps of 14.6 points in 2002 and 14.1 points in 2009 appeared for momentum.
  • In the 100-stock semi-annual momentum case, moving the rebalance by one month produced a twenty percentage-point return difference over a rolling year.

Robustness, as reported in the paper

  • Pairwise long-short tests of rebalance schedules found no statistically significant winner among the fifteen momentum permutations, and similar results for other styles.
  • A simulation-based significance test also found no pair of schedules with returns statistically different from zero.
  • Tracking error of the momentum sub-indices against the RTL-neutral benchmark ranged from 2.9% to 4.6%.

Caveats and limits

  • All returns are gross of transaction fees and advisory expenses, so more frequent rebalancing would lower net returns.
  • The portfolios use simple equal-weight, rank-based factor definitions on one universe and one sample period; the paper calls them representative only.
  • Index replications follow public methodology rules as read in December 2019, so they may differ from the live indices (inferred).
  • Measuring timing luck for discretionary managers without a fixed schedule is hard, as the paper notes.

Items marked (inferred) are our reading of the design, not statements by the authors.

Why it matters

Two managers or an index and a fund can differ by hundreds of basis points a year because of rebalance dates alone. Relative performance comparisons may then reflect luck rather than skill. The paper points to overlapping (staggered) portfolios as a way to neutralize this.

Questions about this paper

What is rebalance timing luck?

It is the performance gap between two identically run strategies that rebalance on different dates. The paper measures it against an equal-weight blend of all schedules.

Which style showed the largest timing luck?

Momentum, a high-turnover style, showed the most. Its replicated index had a 192 basis point annualized gap between best and worst schedule.

Does any rebalance schedule win consistently?

The paper found no statistically significant superior schedule, so it treats timing luck as an uncompensated risk.

Where can I read the original paper?

The original is at its publisher: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3673910. We link to the paper and do not host the PDF.

Follow new quant research

Download MacroFinance market data as CSV or Excel, or pull it by API, and test the ideas in these papers yourself. New summaries are added as we review them.

Create a free account
Summaries are written by MacroFinance from the published papers, in our own words, for information only. They are not investment advice and may omit detail. Papers are not hosted here: each page links to the original at its publisher.