Skip to content

The 60/40 Problem: The Traditional 60/40 Portfolio in an Uncertain Rate Environment: summary and key takeaways

The paper splits U.S. history into interest rate regimes and compares a plain 60/40 portfolio with trend-following versions of it. The trend versions show higher Sharpe ratios in every regime, and in a Japanese 1989-2018 test. The authors are a trend-following manager, so the framing is promotional.

Robinson, J.; Langley, B. · 2017 · SSRNSummary updated 20 November 2026
Published2017Working paper
Asset focusStocks+BondsStrategic allocation
TypePortfolio MgmtStock-Bond Correlation
Reading time4 minthis summary

The 60/40 Problem: The Traditional 60/40 Portfolio in an Uncertain Rate Environment at a glance

The question
Does adding a moving-average trend rule to a 60/40 stock-bond portfolio improve risk-adjusted results in both rising and falling rate regimes?
Dataset & period
U.S. stocks and bonds, with the 10-year Treasury yield used to define rate regimes, January 1900 to July 2018, monthly signals, five regimes. A second test uses Japanese stocks and bonds, January 1989 to August 2018. Data from Global Financial Data.
Method
Each asset is checked monthly against its exponential moving average, using an 8-month (T8) and a 12-month (T12) lookback. Price above the average means uptrend, below means downtrend. The trend portfolios hold 20% buy-and-hold and 80% trend-following. A downtrending asset is cut and the money moves to the other asset or to T-bills. Results are hypothetical backtests with annual rebalancing, no fees.

Key findings of The 60/40 Problem: The Traditional 60/40 Portfolio in an Uncertain Rate Environment

  • The trend-following 60/40 had a higher Sharpe ratio than buy-and-hold in every U.S. rate regime since 1900, per the paper.
  • In the first rising-rate regime, the Sharpe ratio went from 0.47 for buy-and-hold to 0.77 for T8 and 0.78 for T12.
  • In the 1941-1981 rising regime, buy-and-hold had slightly higher CAGR. The authors describe the trade as 20bps of CAGR given up for a 19% Sharpe gain with a lower drawdown.
  • Across the two falling-rate regimes, the paper reports an average Sharpe improvement of 40% over buy-and-hold.
  • In the rising-rate regimes, the trend portfolios beat buy-and-hold in the eight largest 60/40 drawdowns the paper charts.
  • For Japan from 1989, buy-and-hold 60/40 had a Sharpe ratio of 0.03, against 0.54 for T8 and 0.52 for T12.

Robustness, as reported in the paper

  • Two lookbacks (8 and 12 months) give nearly identical results in most regimes.
  • Results are shown separately for five regimes, rising and falling, rather than one full-sample figure.
  • A separate Japanese 60/40 test is used as an example of a long falling-rate period with weak equities.

Caveats and limits

  • All trend results are hypothetical backtests with annual rebalancing. The paper says they exclude fees and expenses.
  • The authors state that trend following does not guarantee future outperformance.
  • The rate regimes are defined with hindsight, and the last regime is only two years long (inferred).
  • The authors are an asset manager that sells trend-following strategies, and the paper argues for that approach (inferred).

Items marked (inferred) are our reading of the design, not statements by the authors.

Why it matters

The paper argues that a 60/40 portfolio is mostly an equity bet, since stocks have driven its risk. It gives one long-history test of a simple rule that moves out of falling assets. Practitioners can use it as a reference for how such a rule behaved across past rate regimes, with the caveats above.

Questions about this paper

Why does the paper say a 60/40 portfolio behaves like an equity portfolio?

It says the stock sleeve has been 3 times as volatile as the bond sleeve. It also cites an earlier paper showing an 80/20 mix had a 99% correlation to all equities.

What did trend following do for 60/40 in falling-rate regimes?

The trend versions had higher Sharpe ratios in both falling regimes, an average improvement of 40% over buy-and-hold.

Did the trend version always beat buy-and-hold on return?

No. In the 1941-1981 regime buy-and-hold had higher CAGR by 20bps, though the trend version had a higher Sharpe ratio.

Where can I read the original paper?

The original is at its publisher: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2959015. We link to the paper and do not host the PDF.

Follow new quant research

Download MacroFinance market data as CSV or Excel, or pull it by API, and test the ideas in these papers yourself. New summaries are added as we review them.

Create a free account
Summaries are written by MacroFinance from the published papers, in our own words, for information only. They are not investment advice and may omit detail. Papers are not hosted here: each page links to the original at its publisher.