Investing Strategies: Backtested Asset Allocation Strategies
Investing strategies, backtested and compared. This screener lists 71 rules-based investing strategies (61 fully backtested): tactical asset allocation, dual momentum, trend following, risk parity and classic lazy portfolios such as the 60/40, Harry Browne's Permanent Portfolio and Ray Dalio's All Weather. Every strategy trades a handful of ETFs, rebalances on a fixed schedule and is backtested by MacroFinance on its own ETF price history, so you can compare annual return, volatility, Sharpe ratio and max drawdown on the same basis.
Filter by risk level (15 conservative, 42 moderate, 14 aggressive), by rebalance frequency or by the asset a strategy holds (try SPY, TLT or Gold), and click a column to sort.
Performance is independently backtested from our own ETF price history (inception onward); figures differ from third-party published numbers. Strategies marked contributor are published by community members; their statistics (r) are contributor-reported and not verified by MacroFinance.
Popular investing strategies compared
Backtested since each strategy's first full year of ETF data. All four are free to explore in full.
| Strategy | Risk | Assets | Ann. return | Volatility | Sharpe | Max drawdown | Since |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Harry Browne's Permanent Portfolio | Conservative | 3 | 7.0% | 7.3% | 0.96 | -17.2% | 2004 |
| 60/40 Benchmark | Moderate | 2 | 8.2% | 8.9% | 0.93 | -29.5% | 2002 |
| PortfolioCharts' Golden Butterfly | Moderate | 5 | 7.4% | 8.2% | 0.91 | -18.0% | 2004 |
| Ray Dalio's All-Weather/All-Seasons Portfolio | Moderate | 5 | 6.4% | 8.2% | 0.80 | -21.6% | 2006 |
Types of investing strategies
Lazy & static portfolios (4)
Fixed weights across stocks, bonds, gold and cash, rebalanced back to target. Simple, cheap and tax-friendly; they never try to time the market.
Harry Browne's Permanent Portfolio · 60/40 Benchmark · PortfolioCharts' Golden Butterfly · Ray Dalio's All-Weather/All-Seasons Portfolio
Risk parity & portfolio optimization (9)
Weight assets by risk instead of money (risk parity, equal risk contribution) or optimize for diversification or the best Sharpe ratio, often combined with a trend filter.
David Varadi's Minimum Correlation Portfolio · Aspect Partners' Risk Managed Momentum · US Max Diversification · US Risk Parity Trend Following · US Max Sharpe · US Min Correlation · Efficiente Index · US Equal Risk Contribution · and 1 more in the table above
Momentum & dual momentum (33)
Hold the assets with the strongest recent returns (relative momentum) and move to bonds or cash when even the leaders lose to cash (absolute momentum). Most Keller & Keuning strategies use a "canary" universe to detect crashes early.
Wouter Keller's Lethargic Asset Allocation · Keller and Keuning's Defensive Asset Allocation · Movement Capital's Composite Strategy · Keller and Keuning's Vigilant Asset Allocation - Aggressive · Keller and Van Putten's Flexible Asset Allocation · Keller and Keuning's Protective Asset Allocation - CPR · Keller and Butler's Elastic Asset Allocation - Defensive · Keller and Butler's Elastic Asset Allocation - Offensive · and 25 more in the table above
Trend following & timing (15)
Own an asset only while its price trend is up, typically above its 10-month moving average, and step aside when it breaks. Designed to cut losses in long bear markets.
Tactical Permanent Portfolio · Zakamulin and Giner's Optimal Trend Following · Dick Stoken's Active Combined Asset (ACA) - Daily Trading · David Varadi's Percentile Channels · Ned Davis' Three Way Model · Dick Stoken's Active Combined Asset (ACA) - Monthly Trading · Meb Faber's Global Tactical Asset Allocation 13 (GTAA 13) · Meb Faber's Global Tactical Asset Allocation - Agg. 6 · and 7 more in the table above
Macro, value & bond strategies (10)
Use economic data (unemployment, growth cycles), valuations or bond-market signals to switch between risk-on and risk-off assets.
Wes Gray's Robust Asset Allocation - Aggressive · Wes Gray's Robust Asset Allocation - Balanced · Paul Novell's Tactical Bond Strategy · Grzegorz Link's Global Growth Cycle · Paul Novell's Bond UI1 · Paul Novell's Bond-COMP · Paul Novell's SPY-COMP · Predicting US Treasury Returns · and 2 more in the table above
Investing strategies FAQ
What are investing strategies?
An investing strategy is a set of rules that decides what you own and when you change it. The strategies on this page are asset allocation strategies: they spread money across ETFs for stocks, bonds, gold, commodities and cash, and rebalance on a fixed schedule using rules such as momentum, trend or risk balancing.
What is the best investing strategy?
There is no single best investing strategy: the right one depends on how much drawdown you can live with, your time horizon and how often you are willing to rebalance. Compare strategies on risk-adjusted return (Sharpe ratio) and worst loss (max drawdown), not on return alone. For example, in our backtests the 60/40 portfolio returned 8.2% a year since 2002 but fell 29.5% at its worst, while Harry Browne's Permanent Portfolio returned 7.0% with a 17.2% max drawdown.
What is tactical asset allocation?
Tactical asset allocation (TAA) changes a portfolio's weights based on market signals instead of holding a fixed mix. A typical TAA strategy checks once a month which assets are trending up or have the strongest momentum, moves into those, and switches to bonds or cash when markets turn risky. The goal is to stay invested in rising markets and cut losses in bear markets.
What is dual momentum investing?
Dual momentum, popularized by Gary Antonacci, combines relative momentum (buy the asset that has gone up the most, for example US vs international stocks) with absolute momentum (only hold it if it beat cash; otherwise hold bonds). Strategies such as Vigilant, Defensive and Protective Asset Allocation by Keller and Keuning extend the idea with more assets and "canary" crash signals.
What is trend following?
Trend following holds an asset only while its price is above a moving average or another trend signal, and sells it when the trend breaks. Meb Faber's Global Tactical Asset Allocation (GTAA) and Ivy Portfolio apply a 10-month moving average to each asset class, which historically cut drawdowns in 2008 compared with buy and hold.
What are lazy portfolios like the Permanent Portfolio and All Weather?
Lazy portfolios hold a fixed mix of asset classes and only rebalance back to target weights. The Permanent Portfolio splits money equally between stocks, long-term Treasuries, gold and cash (backtest: 7.0% a year, Sharpe 0.96). Ray Dalio's All Weather portfolio tilts toward bonds and adds gold and commodities so that no single economic regime dominates (backtest: 6.4% a year, max drawdown 21.6%). The Golden Butterfly adds a small-cap value tilt (7.4% a year).
What is risk parity?
Risk parity sizes each asset so that it contributes the same amount of risk (volatility) to the portfolio, rather than the same amount of money. Because bonds are less volatile than stocks, a risk parity portfolio holds more bonds; trend-following versions also drop assets that are falling.
How are these strategies backtested?
MacroFinance runs every strategy through its own backtest engine on daily ETF price history (from each ETF's inception, the earliest from 2002), rebalancing on the strategy's schedule with total returns. Results are hypothetical, so they may differ from figures published by the original authors, and past performance does not guarantee future results.
What do annual return, Sharpe ratio and max drawdown mean?
Annual return (CAGR) is the compound growth rate per year. Volatility is the annualized standard deviation of returns. The Sharpe ratio is return above cash divided by volatility: higher means more return per unit of risk, and values above 1 are strong for a multi-asset strategy. Max drawdown is the largest peak-to-trough loss, the best guide to how painful a strategy can be to hold.
How often do these strategies trade, and can I follow the signals?
Most strategies rebalance once a month, at month end, so they can be run in an ordinary brokerage account with a few ETFs. Each strategy page shows its current allocation; premium members also see every rebalance signal and can follow strategies to get alerts when the allocation changes.
Backtests are hypothetical and use total-return ETF prices; they exclude taxes and trading costs. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Nothing on this page is investment advice.