Skip to content

Fact, Fiction and Momentum Investing: summary and key takeaways

AQR authors take ten common criticisms of equity momentum and test them with public U.S. factor data and prior studies. They find momentum is large relative to size and value, works on both sides and in large caps, and pairs well with value. They also say it has hard stretches and large crashes.

Asness, C.; Frazzini, A.; Israel, R. et al. · 2014 · The Journal of Portfolio ManagementSummary updated 20 November 2026
Published2014Journal article
Asset focusEquitiesMomentum
TypeStrategyTrend & Momentum
Reading time4 minthis summary

Fact, Fiction and Momentum Investing at a glance

The question
Do the popular criticisms of momentum investing hold up against the available evidence?
Dataset & period
Kenneth French data library U.S. equity factors (market, size, value, momentum), long-short and gross of costs. Full sample 1927 to 2013, plus 1963 to 2013 and 1991 to 2013 sub-periods. Monthly data is implied but not stated explicitly. Cost, tax and international evidence is taken from other studies.
Method
The paper uses the standard up-minus-down momentum factor, which ranks stocks on the past 12 months of return, skipping the latest month. It compares this factor with size and value on average spread returns, Sharpe ratios and share of positive rolling periods. It splits momentum into long and short legs and into small and large caps. It also runs a simple Sharpe-maximizing mix of the four factors and cites other studies for costs, taxes, crashes and theory.

Key findings of Fact, Fiction and Momentum Investing

  • Over 1927 to 2013, the winner-minus-loser spread averaged 8.3% a year. This was higher than the size and value spreads, and the Sharpe ordering was the same.
  • Long and short legs contributed about equally on a market-adjusted basis in the full sample: the short leg added 5.1% and the long leg 5.5%.
  • Momentum is not confined to small caps. Over the full sample, the small-cap version earned 9.8% a year and the large-cap version 6.8%.
  • In the 1991 to 2013 period, large-cap momentum had a Sharpe ratio of 0.24 against 0.45 in small caps. The paper notes this gap is unusually wide for momentum and that value was far weaker among large caps.
  • Momentum and value are negatively correlated, at -0.4 in the full sample. A Sharpe-maximizing mix of the four factors put about 38% in momentum at its average return, and still held a positive weight even when momentum's return was set to zero.
  • The worst full-sample drawdown was -43% for value and -77% for momentum, but only -30% for a value-heavy blend of the two.

Robustness, as reported in the paper

  • The 1991 to 2013 window serves as an out-of-sample check after the original momentum studies, and the factor ordering holds there.
  • Cited work finds that long and short legs are equally profitable in U.S., international and other-asset-class data, and that momentum is unrelated to size in those samples.
  • A cited study using a large institutional trade record finds momentum trading costs low enough that the premium survives them.
  • Cited work finds no sign of weaker momentum returns after publication, as trading costs fell, or as hedge fund and mutual fund assets grew.

Caveats and limits

  • The factor results are long-short and gross of trading costs; the paper itself says long-only access, costs and taxes can still be debated.
  • The authors say momentum has had a harder time in recent years and has large crash episodes, which the paper traces to being short losers after a bear market followed by a sharp rebound.
  • The authors work at a firm that runs momentum and value strategies, so the paper is an advocacy piece rather than a neutral test (inferred).
  • Cost, tax, international and crash evidence comes from other papers that are summarized, not re-run here; some were working papers at the time.

Items marked (inferred) are our reading of the design, not statements by the authors.

Why it matters

The paper collects, in one place, the standard counterarguments to common objections about momentum, with simple data anyone can check. For a practitioner it frames momentum as a factor to size alongside value rather than a stand-alone bet. It also shows where the criticism has some basis, namely the crash risk and the unusually wide small-versus-large-cap gap in recent decades.

Questions about this paper

Does momentum only work on the short side?

No. Over 1927 to 2013 the market-adjusted contribution was 5.1% from the short leg and 5.5% from the long leg, so the two were roughly equal.

Is momentum only a small-cap effect?

No. The paper finds a premium in both: 9.8% a year for small caps and 6.8% for large caps over the full sample, with the gap wider in 1991 to 2013.

Why combine momentum with value?

The two are negatively correlated, at -0.4 in the full sample. The worst drawdown was -77% for momentum alone and -30% for a value-heavy blend.

Where can I read the original paper?

The original is at its publisher: https://doi.org/10.3905/jpm.2014.40.5.075. We link to the paper and do not host the PDF.

Follow new quant research

Download MacroFinance market data as CSV or Excel, or pull it by API, and test the ideas in these papers yourself. New summaries are added as we review them.

Create a free account
Summaries are written by MacroFinance from the published papers, in our own words, for information only. They are not investment advice and may omit detail. Papers are not hosted here: each page links to the original at its publisher.