Skip to content

Breaking Bad Trends: summary and key takeaways

The paper counts the months in which slow and fast momentum signals disagree and links that count to weaker trend-following results. Such turning points became more frequent in the last decade. A dynamic strategy that adjusts after corrections and rebounds earned more than double the static average return in that decade.

Goulding, C.L.; Harvey, C.R.; Mazzoleni, M.G. · 2024 · Financial Analysts JournalSummary updated 20 November 2026
Published2024Journal article
Asset focusMulti-assetTrend following
TypeStrategyTrend & Momentum
Reading time4 minthis summary

Breaking Bad Trends at a glance

The question
How do breaks in price trends affect standard trend-following strategies, and can a strategy be built that handles them better?
Dataset & period
55 futures, forwards and swaps markets: 12 equity indices, 10 bond markets, 24 commodities and 9 currency pairs. Monthly returns; some series start in 1971-01, all run through 2019-12. The evaluation window is 1990-01 to 2019-12, with 1,561 asset-year observations.
Method
Each market gets a slow signal (average of trailing monthly excess returns over a long window) and a fast signal (a short window). A month is a turning point when the two signs disagree. Months are sorted into Bull, Correction, Bear and Rebound. The dynamic strategy follows the static trend in Bull and Bear months. After a Correction or Rebound it blends the slow and fast strategies using weights estimated only from past data.

Key findings of Breaking Bad Trends

  • Across assets, more turning points in a year goes with a lower annual Sharpe ratio for 12-month trend following.
  • With 6 or more turning points in a year, median static trend returns are negative. With 8 or more, most returns are negative.
  • For the multi-asset static portfolio, a one-standard-deviation rise in average yearly turning points (+0.45) goes with about 9.2 percentage points lower annual return. The fitted line has R2 = 0.72.
  • The number of turning points has a correlation of 0.02 with return volatility, so it is not a volatility proxy.
  • Six of the most recent 10 years rank among the top 10 years of the last 30 for turning-point frequency, which helps explain weaker recent trend results.
  • Static multi-asset trend earned about 7.5% a year over 30 years but only 1.8% in the most recent decade. The dynamic version earned 4.3% in that decade.

Robustness, as reported in the paper

  • Mixing parameters are estimated ex ante from past data only, with up to 48 months of history used as warm-up for assets with short samples.
  • Results are described as similar if assets are weighted by inverse volatility instead of equally.
  • The negative link between turning points and performance disappears when assets are binned by volatility instead.
  • Faster static strategies and blends of static strategies also struggle to earn returns after turning points, especially in the recent decade.

Caveats and limits

  • Performance is gross of transaction costs and contract roll costs.
  • The paper notes that a turning point can be a false alarm in noisy periods rather than a true trend break.
  • The 2- and 12-month horizons are one common choice for all assets; the paper says other horizons may suit different assets better.
  • The recent-decade comparison covers one 10-year window, and the exhibit tables are image-based (inferred).

Items marked (inferred) are our reading of the design, not statements by the authors.

Why it matters

The paper gives a measurable reason, the frequency of turning points, for the weak recent record of monthly trend following. It shows how the signal mix could be changed after corrections and rebounds. Practitioners can use the turning-point count as a diagnostic for their own trend books.

Questions about this paper

What is a turning point in this paper?

A month in which the sign of a market's slow momentum signal differs from the sign of its fast signal. It splits into Corrections and Rebounds.

Is a turning point just a high-volatility month?

No. The paper reports a correlation of 0.02 between turning-point counts and return volatility, and no significant link between volatility and trend Sharpe ratios.

How did dynamic trend compare with static trend recently?

In the most recent decade, dynamic trend averaged 4.3% a year against 1.8% for static 12-month trend, with both scaled to 10% volatility.

Where can I read the original paper?

The original is at its publisher: https://doi.org/10.1080/0015198x.2023.2270084. We link to the paper and do not host the PDF.

Follow new quant research

Download MacroFinance market data as CSV or Excel, or pull it by API, and test the ideas in these papers yourself. New summaries are added as we review them.

Create a free account
Summaries are written by MacroFinance from the published papers, in our own words, for information only. They are not investment advice and may omit detail. Papers are not hosted here: each page links to the original at its publisher.