Skip to content

Tactical Asset Allocation with the Relative Total Return CAPE: summary and key takeaways

The paper builds a relative version of the total return CAPE and uses it to switch from US stocks into 10-year Treasury notes when valuations look stretched. The best filter produced 79% more terminal wealth than buy-and-hold over the full sample, but results varied a lot across sub-periods.

Peláez, R.F. · 2021 · The Journal of Portfolio ManagementSummary updated 20 November 2026
Published2021Journal article
Asset focusEquitiesTAA / valuation
TypeBothTactical Allocation
Reading time4 minthis summary

Tactical Asset Allocation with the Relative Total Return CAPE at a glance

The question
Can a CAPE measure scaled by its own recent history give short-term signals for moving between stocks and Treasuries?
Dataset & period
US S&P 500 total return price and 10-year Treasury notes, Shiller data converted to quarterly frequency (last month of each quarter), 1901Q1-2019Q4 for the main simulation; risk-adjusted measures cover 1934Q1-2019Q4.
Method
The total return CAPE (TRC) divides a dividend-reinvested real price by a 10-year average of share-adjusted real earnings. The relative version (RTRC) divides the TRC by its own 80-quarter average. When the RTRC is at or above a threshold, the portfolio holds 10-year Treasuries; otherwise it holds the equity index. Thresholds from 1.2 to 1.94 were tried, and trades happen at quarter-end using data available at the time. Treasury returns are built from Shiller's yield data with a duration and convexity formula.

Key findings of Tactical Asset Allocation with the Relative Total Return CAPE

  • The best threshold, an RTRC of 1.43, ended with terminal wealth of $3,245, which is 79% more than buy-and-hold.
  • Buy-and-hold grew $1 into $1,816 at an annually compounded real return of 6.36%; the 1.43 filter reached 6.85%.
  • During the first 28 quarters spent in Treasuries, the tactical portfolio averaged 3.55% a year against negative 5.95% for buy-and-hold, an edge of 9.5 percentage points.
  • Moving into Treasuries in the early 1990s was costly: buy-and-hold beat the tactical portfolio by 3.87 percentage points in that episode.
  • For filters between 1.41 and 1.44 over 1934Q1-2019Q4, the paper reports positive, statistically significant Jensen alphas and higher Sharpe and Treynor measures than buy-and-hold.
  • Unit root tests reject a unit root for the RTRC at the 5% level, but not for the CAPE or the TRC; the stationarity test rejects for CAPE and TRC at the 1% level and does not reject for the RTRC.

Robustness, as reported in the paper

  • The paper shows terminal wealth across a range of RTRC thresholds and reports the best-performing one, so the headline figure is an in-sample optimum.
  • Sub-sample results differ: the early switch in the late 1920s caused large opportunity losses before the strategy caught up, and the 1990s were also unfavourable.
  • Break-adjusted unit root tests on the CAPE still fail to reject a unit root, with a level break dated 1990Q4.
  • Recursive DF-GLS tests over 300 test samples reject the unit root for the RTRC except for samples ending around 1999-2000.

Caveats and limits

  • The threshold was chosen as the best case over the same history it is evaluated on, with no separate out-of-sample test reported (inferred).
  • Transaction costs and taxes are not mentioned in the simulation (inferred).
  • The author states that the RTRC does not outperform consistently and should not be a mechanical rule, but one input among others.
  • Treasury returns before the daily yield series are derived from monthly yield data with a formula rather than traded prices.

Items marked (inferred) are our reading of the design, not statements by the authors.

Why it matters

The paper shows how normalising a slow-moving valuation ratio by its own history can turn it into a shorter-horizon signal. It also shows the cost of acting on valuation too early, since long stretches in bonds during bull markets drove the weak episodes. Practitioners can use it as a case study in valuation-based tactical switching and in threshold overfitting risk.

Questions about this paper

What is the RTRC?

It is the total return CAPE divided by its own 80-quarter average, which removes much of the long drift that makes the plain CAPE slow to signal.

How much did the tactical switch add versus buy-and-hold?

With the best threshold of 1.43, terminal wealth was $3,245 against $1,816 for buy-and-hold, a 79% increase.

Did the strategy work in every period?

No. The paper reports weak results in the late 1920s and the 1990s, when switching to Treasuries meant missing strong equity markets.

Where can I read the original paper?

The original is at its publisher: https://doi.org/10.3905/jpm.2021.1.206. We link to the paper and do not host the PDF.

Follow new quant research

Download MacroFinance market data as CSV or Excel, or pull it by API, and test the ideas in these papers yourself. New summaries are added as we review them.

Create a free account
Summaries are written by MacroFinance from the published papers, in our own words, for information only. They are not investment advice and may omit detail. Papers are not hosted here: each page links to the original at its publisher.