Skip to content

Tactical Allocation research papers, summarized

This topic collects 11 summarized papers on tactical allocation: faber, dual momentum, DAA, PAA, LAA and RAA: rules for rotating between asset classes. Each summary gives the question, the data, the method, the key findings and the caveats, and links to the original paper.

Updated 20 November 202611 summariesSummaries by MacroFinance

Tactical Allocation papers

A Quantitative Approach to Tactical Asset Allocation (Faber)

Faber, M.T. · 2007 · The Journal of Wealth Management

Faber tests a monthly rule that holds an asset only when its price is above its 10-month simple moving average, otherwise cash. Applied to the S&P 500 since 1901 and to a five-asset portfolio since 1973, it lowers volatility and drawdown. The 2013 update adds the 2006-2012 out-of-sample period.

Multi-assetTAA

Accelerating Dual Momentum

· Allocate Smartly

AllocateSmartly backtests a one-asset-at-a-time tactical strategy that rotates between US large caps, international small caps and bonds using short-term momentum. Net of costs, it beat a 60/40 benchmark over 1990 to August 2018, but with much higher volatility. The authors warn that results look sensitive to the trading day and rest on a short history.

Practitioner researchMulti-assetMomentum / TAA

Breadth Momentum and the Canary Universe: Defensive Asset Allocation (DAA)

Keller, W.J.; Keuning, J.W. · 2018 · SSRN Electronic Journal

The paper replaces the crash signal of Vigilant Asset Allocation with a separate two-asset canary universe (VWO and BND). In backtests the average cash fraction falls to less than half that of the earlier strategy, while return and return-to-risk are mostly similar or better.

Multi-assetMomentum / TAA

Dual Momentum: Testing the Dual Momentum Strategy and Implications for Lifetime Allocations

Ha, S.; Fabozzi, F.J. · 2022 · The Journal of Portfolio Management

The paper tests Antonacci's dual momentum rule on US equity indexes and T-bills, first as an allocation framework and then as an overlay on target date funds. Returns beat a static benchmark in every formation period, but Sharpe ratio gains are not statistically significant, and Monte Carlo results are weaker than historical ones.

Multi-assetMomentum / TAA

Global Equity Momentum: A Craftsman's Perspective

Butler, A. et al. (ReSolve Asset Management) · 2019 · ReSolve Asset Management

The article replicates the Global Equity Momentum (dual momentum) strategy and tests many lookback variants against it. It finds the original twelve-month version is statistically indistinguishable from the alternatives, while an ensemble of all variants produced similar long-run returns with smaller drawdowns and steadier shorter-horizon outcomes.

Practitioner researchMulti-assetMomentum / TAA

Global Tactical Cross-Asset Allocation: Applying Value and Momentum Across Asset Classes

Blitz, D.C.; Vliet, P.V. · 2008 · The Journal of Portfolio Management

The paper ranks 12 asset classes each month on momentum and a simple yield-based value measure, then compares top and bottom quartiles. Momentum and value each earned positive long/short returns, and a combined score earned 11.9% a year, with results holding after several adjustments.

Multi-assetTAA

Growth-Trend Timing and 60-40 Variations: Lethargic Asset Allocation (LAA)

Keller, W.J. · 2019 · SSRN Electronic Journal

The paper applies growth-trend timing, which flags a bear market only when both US unemployment and the S&P 500 trend badly, to a 60-40 style portfolio. A search on an early sample yields LAA, which switches between two near-identical four-asset portfolios. Over the full sample LAA earned more than 60-40 with about half the maximum drawdown.

Multi-assetTAA

Lazy Momentum with Growth-Trend Timing: Resilient Asset Allocation (RAA)

Keller, W.J. · 2020 · SSRN Electronic Journal

The paper builds Resilient Asset Allocation (RAA) from the earlier Lethargic Asset Allocation (LAA) in three steps: a five-asset equal-weight portfolio, a faster market filter and a slower unemployment filter. Over the full backtest RAA shows a higher CAGR and a smaller maximum drawdown than LAA and than a 60/40 benchmark, with turnover that stays low.

Multi-assetTAA

Protective Asset Allocation (PAA)

Keller, W.J.; Keuning, J.W. · 2016 · SSRN Electronic Journal

The paper adds a breadth-based bond fraction to a simple moving-average dual momentum model. In the most protective setting, drawdowns stay far below those of dual momentum, a stock/bond mix and the S&P 500 ETF, while returns remain above the stock/bond mix.

Multi-assetTAA

Simple and Effective Market Timing with Tactical Asset Allocation

Glenn, L.A. · 2014 · SSRN

The paper tests a monthly rule that holds either a U.S. equity ETF or a long Treasury ETF, whichever rose more over a recent look-back window. Over the 10 years to 12/31/13 it beat the Ivy 5 moving-average portfolio on total return and trade count, but had a somewhat deeper maximum drawdown.

Stocks+BondsTAA

Tactical Asset Allocation with the Relative Total Return CAPE

Peláez, R.F. · 2021 · The Journal of Portfolio Management

The paper builds a relative version of the total return CAPE and uses it to switch from US stocks into 10-year Treasury notes when valuations look stretched. The best filter produced 79% more terminal wealth than buy-and-hold over the full sample, but results varied a lot across sub-periods.

EquitiesTAA / valuation

Other quant research topics

Trend & Momentum

Time-series and cross-sectional momentum, trend-following robustness and how it behaves in crises.

13 summaries

Stock-Bond Correlation

What drives the sign of the stock-bond correlation and what it means for diversification and 60/40.

10 summaries

Volatility & VIX

VIX methodology, term structure, volatility as an asset class and realized-volatility forecasting.

7 summaries

Portfolio Construction & Risk

Markowitz, 1/N, hierarchical risk parity, volatility targeting, drawdowns and rebalancing.

9 summaries

Inflation & Macro

Inflation regimes, recession prediction and portfolios built for changing macro conditions.

8 summaries

Regimes & Safe Havens

Dating bull and bear markets, regime models, and which assets act as havens in a crisis.

8 summaries

Quant Crises & Methods

The 2007 and 2020 quant drawdowns, and how to test and read factor research.

8 summaries

Equity Markets & Premia

The equity risk premium and short-horizon patterns in equity returns.

3 summaries

More Tactical Allocation research

Download MacroFinance market data as CSV or Excel, or pull it by API, and test the ideas in these papers yourself. New summaries are added as we review them.

Create a free account
Summaries are written by MacroFinance from the published papers, in our own words, for information only. They are not investment advice and may omit detail. Papers are not hosted here: each page links to the original at its publisher.