Skip to content

Quant Crises & Methods research papers, summarized

This topic collects 8 summarized papers on quant crises & methods: the 2007 and 2020 quant drawdowns, and how to test and read factor research. Each summary gives the question, the data, the method, the key findings and the caveats, and links to the original paper.

Updated 20 November 20268 summariesSummaries by MacroFinance

Quant Crises & Methods papers

A Backtesting Protocol in the Era of Machine Learning

Arnott, R.D.; Harvey, C.R.; Markowitz, H. · 2018 · SSRN

The paper argues that finance data are too limited for machine learning to be used without discipline. It shows a nonsense ticker-letter strategy that passes a simple train/validate split, then sets out a seven-category protocol to reduce false discoveries.

Asset-agnosticBacktesting

Alice's Adventures in Factorland: Three Blunders That Plague Factor Investing

Arnott, R.; Harvey, C.R.; Kalesnik, V. et al. · 2019 · The Journal of Portfolio Management

The paper argues that investors misjudge factor investing in three ways: they expect too much return, they underestimate tail losses, and they overstate diversification across factors. Using US long-short factors, it shows returns fell after publication and that factor portfolios suffered a deep, clustered drawdown that normal-distribution models miss.

EquitiesFactor investing

Be Skeptical of Asset Management Research

Harvey, C.R. · 2021 · SSRN

This short essay argues that career and fee incentives push both academic and asset management researchers toward p-hacking and overfitted backtests. The author says the problem is somewhat milder in practice because of performance fees and reputation, but investors should still be skeptical of both.

Asset-agnosticResearch methodology

Open Source Cross-Sectional Asset Pricing

Chen, A.Y.; Zimmermann, T. · 2021 · Finance and Economics Discussion Series

The authors wrote open code for 319 firm-level stock return predictors and compared reproduced t-stats with hand-collected figures from the original papers. Nearly all predictors that were clearly significant in the originals reproduce. The paper argues that claims of widespread replication failure come from loose definitions of what counts as an anomaly.

EquitiesFactor library

Quant Bust 2020

Kakushadze, Z. · 2020 · SSRN

The paper explains in non-technical terms why dollar-neutral quant strategies, mainly mean-reversion statistical arbitrage, suffered drawdowns in the COVID-19 selloff. It argues the strategies depend on stable stock correlations that forced long-only liquidation breaks. Illustrative backtests show mean-reversion drawdowns and gains for momentum and overnight signals.

EquitiesQuant drawdowns

The Quant Crisis of 2018-2020: Cornered by Big Growth

Blitz, D. · 2021 · The Journal of Portfolio Management

The paper studies equity factor portfolios across the June 2018 to August 2020 Quant Crisis. Almost all gains were found in the biggest, priciest growth names, while smaller stocks lagged everywhere. Past value drawdowns were mostly momentum rallies, so this one hit multi-factor managers harder.

EquitiesQuant drawdowns

The Quant Cycle

Blitz, D. · 2021 · SSRN

The paper checks whether business cycle and sentiment indicators explain swings in equity factor returns, and finds they explain little. It then defines a Quant Cycle read directly from factor returns: a normal stage, a value-factor drawdown, and a reversal. This simple stage model separates factor outcomes far better than the macro indicators do.

EquitiesQuant drawdowns

What Happened to the Quants in August 2007?

Khandani, A.E.; Lo, A.W. · 2007 · SSRN

The paper uses a simple daily contrarian equity strategy and hedge-fund database evidence to explain the quant losses of the week of August 6, 2007. It argues that a sudden liquidation of one or more market-neutral portfolios started the losses, and that forced de-leveraging by other funds spread them. The authors call this a tentative hypothesis based on indirect evidence.

EquitiesQuant drawdowns

Other quant research topics

Trend & Momentum

Time-series and cross-sectional momentum, trend-following robustness and how it behaves in crises.

13 summaries

Tactical Allocation

Faber, dual momentum, DAA, PAA, LAA and RAA: rules for rotating between asset classes.

11 summaries

Stock-Bond Correlation

What drives the sign of the stock-bond correlation and what it means for diversification and 60/40.

10 summaries

Volatility & VIX

VIX methodology, term structure, volatility as an asset class and realized-volatility forecasting.

7 summaries

Portfolio Construction & Risk

Markowitz, 1/N, hierarchical risk parity, volatility targeting, drawdowns and rebalancing.

9 summaries

Inflation & Macro

Inflation regimes, recession prediction and portfolios built for changing macro conditions.

8 summaries

Regimes & Safe Havens

Dating bull and bear markets, regime models, and which assets act as havens in a crisis.

8 summaries

Equity Markets & Premia

The equity risk premium and short-horizon patterns in equity returns.

3 summaries

More Quant Crises & Methods research

Download MacroFinance market data as CSV or Excel, or pull it by API, and test the ideas in these papers yourself. New summaries are added as we review them.

Create a free account
Summaries are written by MacroFinance from the published papers, in our own words, for information only. They are not investment advice and may omit detail. Papers are not hosted here: each page links to the original at its publisher.