Skip to content

The Quant Cycle: summary and key takeaways

The paper checks whether business cycle and sentiment indicators explain swings in equity factor returns, and finds they explain little. It then defines a Quant Cycle read directly from factor returns: a normal stage, a value-factor drawdown, and a reversal. This simple stage model separates factor outcomes far better than the macro indicators do.

Blitz, D. · 2021 · SSRNSummary updated 20 November 2026
Published2021Working paper
Asset focusEquitiesQuant drawdowns
TypeResearchQuant Crises & Methods
Reading time4 minthis summary

The Quant Cycle at a glance

The question
Can the time variation in equity factor returns be explained by business cycle indicators, or do factors follow a cycle of their own?
Dataset & period
U.S. factors (value, quality, momentum, low-risk, two versions each, plus an equally weighted mix), monthly, July 1963 to December 2020. A pre-sample extension covers January 1929 to June 1963 for a reduced set of factors. Investor sentiment data is used only where available.
Method
The author first sorts factor returns by NBER recession, inflation regime, ISM level and Baker-Wurgler investor sentiment. He then marks peaks and troughs in factor returns by hand to define stages: normal, growth rally or value crash (a value drawdown), and bear or bull reversal. Average factor returns are reported for each stage. The author calls the method part art and part science.

Key findings of The Quant Cycle

  • NBER expansions versus recessions separate the market factor (8.8% in expansions, -7.4% in recessions) but barely separate the other factors. Recessions cover 12% of the sample.
  • Inflationary periods make up 25% of the sample. The market averaged -5.1% in them, and momentum factors had double-digit positive returns. The value and quality factors looked largely unaffected.
  • ISM readings below 50 occur 27% of the time and show little link to factor returns.
  • Investor sentiment separates factor returns better than macro indicators do. Value, quality and low-risk factors do well when sentiment is positive and poorly when it is negative. Expected factor premiums stay positive in all states.
  • The normal stage lasts about two-thirds of the time and factor returns in it are solid. Growth rallies or value crashes come about once every ten years and last about two years. Value loses heavily and momentum usually gains.
  • Bear reversals (growth stock crashes) are very good for multi-factor mixes. Bull reversals (rebounds of past losers) are hard on most factors except value, and the equally weighted mix has a large negative average return. The paper puts the unconditional chance of moving from normal to a value drawdown within a year at 16%.

Robustness, as reported in the paper

  • A pre-1963 extension (January 1929 to June 1963) shows results broadly consistent with the later sample. It contains several value crashes and bull reversals in the 1930s but no growth rallies or bear reversals.
  • Alternative factors (earnings-to-price and cash-flow-to-price value, long-term and short-term reversal, q-factor ROE and expected growth, PEAD, financing, CMS) behave in line with their correlations to the base factors.
  • Individual episodes within each stage mostly agree with the stage averages, with some stated exceptions, such as quality in the late-1990s tech bubble and momentum in 1980-1981.

Caveats and limits

  • Stages are identified by hand with hindsight, and the author says others might choose different breakpoints. The paper offers no real-time rule for spotting a stage.
  • The sample holds only one value crash after 1963, so stage-level conclusions for value crashes rest on a single episode.
  • The paper says there are too few stage transitions to estimate conditional transition probabilities reliably.
  • No transaction costs or implementation analysis are reported for any factor (inferred).

Items marked (inferred) are our reading of the design, not statements by the authors.

Why it matters

The paper shows that factor performance depends strongly on which stage of the cycle is under way, and that macro labels such as recession or ISM level add little. For factor investors it frames growth rallies and reversals as the main sources of multi-factor risk, and it points to idiosyncratic momentum as a way to soften losses in bull reversals.

Questions about this paper

Do recessions explain factor returns?

Not much. Only the market factor shows a big spread between expansions (8.8%) and recessions (-7.4%). Value returns are almost the same in both states.

How often do value drawdowns happen in the Quant Cycle?

About once every ten years, typically lasting about two years. The normal stage fills about two-thirds of the time.

What is a bull reversal versus a bear reversal?

A bear reversal is a crash of growth stocks that rallied before, which lifts value. A bull reversal is a rebound of the worst past performers, which hurts momentum.

Where can I read the original paper?

The original is at its publisher: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3930006. We link to the paper and do not host the PDF.

Follow new quant research

Download MacroFinance market data as CSV or Excel, or pull it by API, and test the ideas in these papers yourself. New summaries are added as we review them.

Create a free account
Summaries are written by MacroFinance from the published papers, in our own words, for information only. They are not investment advice and may omit detail. Papers are not hosted here: each page links to the original at its publisher.