Skip to content

Regimes & Safe Havens research papers, summarized

This topic collects 8 summarized papers on regimes & safe havens: dating bull and bear markets, regime models, and which assets act as havens in a crisis. Each summary gives the question, the data, the method, the key findings and the caveats, and links to the original paper.

Updated 20 November 20268 summariesSummaries by MacroFinance

Regimes & Safe Havens papers

Defining and Dating Bull and Bear Markets: Two Centuries of Evidence

Gonzalez, L.; Hoang, P.; Massey, J.G.P. et al. · 2006 · Multinational Finance Journal

The paper defines bull and bear markets as persistent shifts in the mean return and dates them in a long US stock index with two detection methods. Both methods find distinct return states that a constant-drift random walk does not explain. Simple timing rules built on the dates cut risk in the out-of-sample tests.

EquitiesBull/bear regimes

Identifying Bull and Bear Market Regimes with a Robust Rule-Based Method

Zegadło, P. · 2022 · Research in International Business and Finance

The paper proposes a bull and bear regime dating rule with one discrete parameter, built by repeatedly filtering peaks and troughs. It compares the rule with two multi-parameter rule-based methods and a Markov-switching model. The new rule matched or beat the others on Sharpe ratio in a simple long-only trading test, most clearly on assets unlike equity indices.

EquitiesBull/bear regimes

Is Bitcoin a Hedge? How Extreme Volatility Can Destroy the Hedge Property

Baur, D.G.; Hoang, L.T.; Hossain, M.Z. · 2022 · Finance Research Letters

The paper asks whether adding Bitcoin to an S&P500 portfolio lowers risk, given Bitcoin's very high volatility. With monthly data the risk-minimizing Bitcoin weight is 0%, and with daily data it is small. The authors argue that correlation alone is a poor guide when one asset is far more volatile than the other.

CryptoSafe haven

Is Gold a Safe Haven in All Currencies?

Baur, D.G. · 2021 · SSRN

The paper tests whether gold protects against stock market losses for investors in 68 countries, measuring gold in local currency and in US dollars. Measured in local currency, gold protects in more than 60 of the markets. Currency moves strengthen or weaken the effect, and the result is weaker for US dollar investors.

GoldSafe haven

Regime Changes and Financial Markets

Ang, A.; Timmermann, A. · 2011 · National Bureau of Economic Research

This survey explains how regime switching models describe abrupt, persistent shifts in markets. It shows that they reproduce skewness, fat tails, volatility clustering and higher correlations in downturns, and that ignoring regimes is costly for asset allocation.

Asset-agnosticRegimes

Searching for Safe-Haven Assets During the COVID-19 Pandemic

Ji, Q.; Zhang, D.; Zhao, Y. · 2020 · International Review of Financial Analysis

The paper tests whether bitcoin, gold, two currency pairs, crude oil and soybean futures protected equity portfolios in the early COVID-19 crash. It monitors left-tail stability of returns and of pairwise portfolios with equity indices. Gold and soybean futures held up as safe havens; most other candidates lost their protective role.

Multi-assetSafe haven

The 2008 GFC and COVID-19 Pandemic: How Safe are the Safe Haven Assets?

Cheema, M.A.; Faff, R.; Szulczyk, K.R. · 2022 · International Review of Financial Analysis

The paper tests whether assets that sheltered investors in the 2008 crisis did so again in the COVID-19 crash. The dollar index and the franc index were the more useful havens in the GFC, while gold and silver behaved like risky assets in many COVID settings. Safe-haven character weakened for gold, silver, the dollar and the franc.

Multi-assetSafe haven

Using the Hidden Markov Model to Classify the S&P 500 [web]

Johnson-Skinner, E. · 2021 · Medium

The article fits a hidden Markov model to daily SPY volatility to label S&P 500 market regimes, first with two states and then with three. It then feeds a one-day-ahead volatility forecast from a DD-EWMA model into the HMM to project the next day's regime.

Practitioner researchEquitiesRegimes / HMM

Other quant research topics

Trend & Momentum

Time-series and cross-sectional momentum, trend-following robustness and how it behaves in crises.

13 summaries

Tactical Allocation

Faber, dual momentum, DAA, PAA, LAA and RAA: rules for rotating between asset classes.

11 summaries

Stock-Bond Correlation

What drives the sign of the stock-bond correlation and what it means for diversification and 60/40.

10 summaries

Volatility & VIX

VIX methodology, term structure, volatility as an asset class and realized-volatility forecasting.

7 summaries

Portfolio Construction & Risk

Markowitz, 1/N, hierarchical risk parity, volatility targeting, drawdowns and rebalancing.

9 summaries

Inflation & Macro

Inflation regimes, recession prediction and portfolios built for changing macro conditions.

8 summaries

Quant Crises & Methods

The 2007 and 2020 quant drawdowns, and how to test and read factor research.

8 summaries

Equity Markets & Premia

The equity risk premium and short-horizon patterns in equity returns.

3 summaries

More Regimes & Safe Havens research

Download MacroFinance market data as CSV or Excel, or pull it by API, and test the ideas in these papers yourself. New summaries are added as we review them.

Create a free account
Summaries are written by MacroFinance from the published papers, in our own words, for information only. They are not investment advice and may omit detail. Papers are not hosted here: each page links to the original at its publisher.