Skip to content

The Impact of Volatility Targeting: summary and key takeaways

The paper compares constant-exposure positions with volatility-scaled positions across more than 60 assets and two multi-asset portfolios. Scaling lifts Sharpe ratios for equities and credit, but not for bonds, currencies or commodities. It reduces extreme returns and the volatility of volatility in all asset classes.

Harvey, C.R.; Hoyle, E.; Korgaonkar, R. et al. · 2018 · The Journal of Portfolio ManagementSummary updated 20 November 2026
Published2018Journal article
Asset focusMulti-assetVolatility targeting
TypePortfolio MgmtPortfolio Construction & Risk
Reading time4 minthis summary

The Impact of Volatility Targeting at a glance

The question
Does targeting constant volatility improve risk-adjusted returns and tail risk only for equities, or across asset classes and portfolios?
Dataset & period
US equity returns from the Kenneth French library (daily, 1927-2017, with three sub-periods and ten industry portfolios); US bonds proxied from yields; US credit hedged with Treasuries; S&P 500 and Treasury futures with 5-minute data; 50 futures and forwards (1988-2017); balanced and risk parity portfolios (1988-2017). The paper describes the full study as spanning over 60 assets, the oldest daily series starting in 1926. The volatility target is 10% annualized.
Method
Each asset's daily excess return is scaled by the inverse of an exponentially weighted volatility estimate known a day ahead. A constant makes the full-sample realized volatility equal to the target, so scaled and unscaled series are comparable. Performance is judged on monthly returns using Sharpe ratio, volatility of volatility, mean shortfall and mean exceedance. For portfolios, scaling is applied at asset level only, or at both asset and portfolio level.

Key findings of The Impact of Volatility Targeting

  • Scaling US equity exposure by volatility lifts the Sharpe ratio from 0.40 to a range of 0.48 to 0.51, and the result changes little with the volatility estimator chosen.
  • Volatility of volatility for US equities falls from 4.6% unscaled to 1.8% scaled, and very negative months become less frequent.
  • For US bonds, scaling lowers the Sharpe ratio over the 1960s to 2017 sample because low-volatility years before 1980 coincided with a bond bear market. Over the futures sample, the Sharpe ratio and left tail are similar to unscaled, with lower volatility of volatility.
  • For credit, a fast volatility estimate raises the Sharpe ratio substantially, while slower estimates reverse the gain and leave the left tail worse than unscaled.
  • Across the 50 futures and forwards, the Sharpe ratio improves slightly for equity indices and is similar elsewhere, while volatility of volatility and mean shortfall improve for almost all assets.
  • Worst-case losses shrink: US equities go from -60.9% to -42.8%, the balanced portfolio from -28.1% to -22.2%, and the risk parity portfolio from -42.1% to -32.1%.
  • The leverage effect, meaning returns fall as volatility rises, is seen in equities and credit but not elsewhere. The momentum-like exposure it creates explains part of the cross-asset Sharpe gain: R-squared of 45% with a fast estimate and 60% with a slower one.

Robustness, as reported in the paper

  • The equity Sharpe gain is statistically significant: the intercept of scaled on unscaled daily returns has a t-stat of 3.05 (Newey-West corrected).
  • The equity Sharpe gain appears in every case except the 1957-1987 subsample. Improvements in vol of vol and mean shortfall also show up in the subsamples and in ten industry portfolios.
  • Gross and net Sharpe ratios for equities are the same at reported precision, using current-era cost estimates applied to the full history. Results are similar with equal-weight windows and 3- or 5-day returns (not reported).
  • Intraday 5-minute volatility estimates give slightly better results than daily estimates for S&P 500 and Treasury futures at similar turnover.

Caveats and limits

  • Transaction costs are estimates from the post-2008 period and may not represent earlier decades; roll costs for futures are not included.
  • The detailed equity and bond results are US-only; the authors note the US is an ex-post winner, and bonds seen as credit-like could behave differently.
  • Bond results depend on the sample: volatility regimes changed over decades, so the pre-1980s period weighs heavily on the full-sample result.
  • Drawdown figures come from a single realized path, which the authors themselves call not robust (inferred caution for reading the drawdown numbers).

Items marked (inferred) are our reading of the design, not statements by the authors.

Why it matters

The paper shows that the benefit of volatility targeting depends on asset class and on how much risk-asset exposure a portfolio holds. For portfolios built around equities and credit, such as 60-40 or risk parity, scaling at both asset and portfolio level improved Sharpe and tails in the sample. It also separates the Sharpe effect from the tail effect, which matters when choosing what scaling is meant to achieve.

Questions about this paper

Does volatility targeting improve Sharpe ratios for every asset?

No. The paper finds gains for risk assets such as equities and credit, and a negligible effect for bonds, currencies and commodities.

Why does volatility scaling help equities and credit?

Both show a leverage effect, so volatility rises when returns fall. Scaling then cuts exposure after losses, which acts like a momentum overlay.

What does volatility targeting do to tail risk?

Across asset classes it makes extreme returns less likely, because big left-tail losses tend to arrive when volatility is high, which is when scaled positions are smallest.

Where can I read the original paper?

The original is at its publisher: https://doi.org/10.3905/jpm.2018.45.1.014. We link to the paper and do not host the PDF.

Follow new quant research

Download MacroFinance market data as CSV or Excel, or pull it by API, and test the ideas in these papers yourself. New summaries are added as we review them.

Create a free account
Summaries are written by MacroFinance from the published papers, in our own words, for information only. They are not investment advice and may omit detail. Papers are not hosted here: each page links to the original at its publisher.